← Learn
Which loan offer is better?
3 min read · Updated November 2026
Short answer
The cheapest offer depends on how long you’ll keep the loan.
A lower rate with high upfront fees only wins if you keep the loan long enough.
What to compare
Every lender has to send you a 3-page Loan Estimate within 3 business days of applying. They all use the same form, so you can line them up.
Page 1Rate and monthly payment
Page 2, box AThe lender’s own fees and points
Page 3What you’d pay in 5 years
An example
Offer 16.875% · $1,495 in fees
Offer 26.5% · $6,895 in fees and points
On a $400,000 loan kept 7 years, Offer 2 saves about $5,200. Moving within 3 years? Offer 1 is cheaper.
Ask the other lender to match
Lenders often will. Send them this:
Hi [name],
Thanks for the Loan Estimate dated [date]. I have another offer for the same [loan amount] loan at [rate], with [fees] in lender fees and points. Over the [number] years I expect to keep the loan, it costs about [savings] less than yours.
I’d like to work with you. Can you lower your rate or fees to match? I’ve attached the other offer.
Thanks,
[Your name]
Before closing
You’ll get a Closing Disclosure at least 3 business days before closing. Compare it to your Loan Estimate. The lender’s own fees generally can’t go up.
General information, not financial or legal advice.